Hayward Poolvergnuegen "The Pool Cleaner" (2X).
Self-adjusting turbine vanes tune the flow to your pump, four-wheel drive climbs walls and grips steps, and tire treads swap for different surfaces. It just works, for years.

The Verdict.
Gavler Meta-Score
“Dana Whitfield's call: if you want a cleaner that costs a fraction of a robot and runs forever off your pump, this is the one. The self-adjusting vanes are why it cleans well on almost any pump, and the durability is legendary. Just expect to clean your filter more often — that's the suction-side tax.”
The Gavler Verdict
The Gavler Review.
Hayward Poolvergnuegen Review: The Suction Cleaner Others Chase
The Hayward Poolvergnuegen, sold as The PoolCleaner, is a 9.1 on Gavler and the number one pick on our Best Suction-Side Pool Cleaners list. It earns that spot by being simple: no electronics, no booster pump, easy setup, and a reputation for not clogging. The biggest catch is that the name covers more than one machine. The two-wheel version one major outlet tested does not climb walls, while the four-wheel version another tested climbed best of its group. Know which you are buying, and expect it to be slow.
What it is
A suction-side cleaner hooks to your skimmer or suction port and uses your pool pump to move and pull debris into the filter. Hayward's version uses self-adjusting turbine vanes and deep-tread wheels, and comes in two-wheel and four-wheel configurations. Our product card lists the four-wheel traits (wall climbing, step gripping), but names the product with a "2X" suffix and shows $399. We could not reconcile that, so we lean on reviewers who named the exact model.
What reviewers found
We found two genuinely hands-on sources for this product, covering different versions.
Family Handyman (two-wheel). Content Director Nicole Doster tested the two-wheel Poolvergnuegen for over three months in a 24 by 16 foot pool (article by Mary Henn, originally August 2024, since updated). She said it "was slow and steady and picked up most of the debris." Under a deliberate dump of four cups of dirt and debris it filled the filter within minutes and kept getting stuck, which she attributed to the load, not a defect. A second owner, Bobby Attonito, said a 15 by 30 foot kidney-shaped pool takes roughly three hours, and that it did not clog even on small stones that jammed his earlier vacuums. The listed cons were that it does not climb walls or stairs and does not act as a skimmer.
Bob Vila (four-wheel W3PVS40JST). Paul Rankin's team ran six suction cleaners through five tests over two weeks in a Florida inground pool (published June 2026). It judged the Hayward "handled climbing the walls of our pool the most consistently" of the group, and said "Setup was super easy compared to some other suction cleaners." The team also said it struggled slightly with curved corners, and that the narrow ribbed wheels scrub less aggressively than the disc-style Zodiac MX6. Its cons list included "Very pricey." Overall it called the Hayward one of the strongest performers it tested.
Secondary sources, not hands-on tests. Pool Magazine's roundup named it Best Suction Cleaner, crediting the self-adjusting turbine vanes, but its page does not describe how it tested (article from 2022). Swim University's suction cleaner guide does not discuss the Hayward at all; its general view was that the Pentair cleaners are the best bang for the buck. Forbes Vetted listed the two-wheel model as its suction pick but did not describe hands-on testing for it.
Strengths
- Hard to clog. Family Handyman's tester and owner source both describe it handling small stones and typical debris without jamming.
- Easy to start. Family Handyman put assembly under 10 minutes in its best-vacuum roundup; Bob Vila said no adjustments were needed.
- No power source, no electronics. It runs on your pump, which is the root of both its reliability case and its limits.
- Four-wheel climbing. In the one test where it was set against five rivals, it was the most consistent wall climber.
Trade-offs and who should skip it
It is slow. Hours per cycle is normal, and its pattern of moving several feet then pivoting makes it hard to aim at a trouble spot.
Version confusion is real. Buy the two-wheel expecting wall cleaning and you will be disappointed.
Corners and heavy debris. Bob Vila saw it stumble on curved corners. Family Handyman's heavy debris test overwhelmed the filter quickly. Pool Magazine's pros are positive, but Forbes noted that suction cleaners struggle in tight corners generally.
Price. Bob Vila called it very pricey. Family Handyman linked a $509 Amazon listing and cited $429 for the 2X and $459 for the 4X in the same article, figures that conflict with each other. Gavler's own listings show $399. Check the current price before you buy.
The suction tax. Everything it picks up lands in your filter, so expect to clean it more often. That is inherent to the design, and none of the reviews contradicted it.
Skip it if you have a lot of falling leaves, a pool with tight curves you care about, or you want a cleaner that is fast and aggressive on walls and waterline.
How it compares
Within our list, the closest rival for wall work is the Zodiac MX6 Elite, which Bob Vila compared directly: its disc-style scrubbing is more aggressive than the Hayward's narrow wheels. If you want to spend less and favor value, the Pentair Kreepy Krauly is the pick Swim University points to in general terms, though that is a category-level recommendation, not a head-to-head test. Our other options are on the full Best Suction-Side Pool Cleaners list.
A note on our own product card
We could not verify three things on our card against independent reviews. First, we could not verify the quotes attributed to Wirecutter, PoolCleanerReviews and Swim University (the Swim University guide we read does not discuss this cleaner), so we have not relied on them. Second, the "legendary durability" claim has owner support in Family Handyman's three-month test, but nothing longer. Third, the idea that it costs a fraction of a robot is true in principle, yet Bob Vila still marked it down on price.
The Gavler verdict
The Hayward Poolvergnuegen is a 9.1 for the owner who wants a dependable, quiet, set-and-forget floor cleaner and does not mind a slow cycle and a busier filter. Choose the four-wheel version if you want walls. The reviews we read back up simplicity and reliability more than they back superlatives. If you are weighing price, compare it against the neighbors on our Best Suction-Side Pool Cleaners list before you commit.
Common Questions
For a floor-focused, low-maintenance suction cleaner, reviewers say yes. Family Handyman's Nicole Doster recommended the two-wheel version after months of use, and Bob Vila's testers called the four-wheel one of the strongest performers of six. Both flagged limits, and Bob Vila listed it as very pricey.
It depends on the version. Family Handyman, testing the two-wheel model, listed that it does not climb walls or stairs. Bob Vila, testing the four-wheel W3PVS40JST, said it handled wall climbing the most consistently of the six cleaners it tested.
Hayward sells both under The PoolCleaner name. The two-wheel version tested by Family Handyman did not climb walls. The four-wheel version tested by Bob Vila climbed well. Check which one you are buying, because reviews of one do not transfer cleanly to the other.
It runs off your existing pump and filter, so it needs no separate power. Pool Magazine credits the self-adjusting turbine vanes for its power, but a suction cleaner will always depend on your pump and a clean filter.
Slowly. Family Handyman's owner source, Bobby Attonito, said a full pool takes roughly three hours, and tester Nicole Doster called it slow and steady. Expect to run it for hours, not minutes.
Where to Buy.
Prices checked regularly
Some links are affiliate links — Gavler may earn a commission. This never affects rankings or scores. Learn more.
Precision Engineering
Self-Adjusting Turbine Vanes
Automatically tune internal flow to your pump's output, so it keeps cleaning across weak and strong pumps alike instead of stalling.
Four-Wheel Drive
Drives up walls, grips steps, and powers out of corners that strand cheaper suction cleaners.
Swappable Tire Treads
Tire treads change to match plaster, vinyl, or fiberglass surfaces for the right grip on your pool.
Technical Specifications
The Scoreboard
The near-consensus best suction cleaner among pool-gear outlets and owners, praised for self-adjusting flow and durability. The unavoidable knock is added filter maintenance.
Cast Your Vote
Do you think Hayward Poolvergnuegen "The Pool Cleaner" (2X) deserves the #1 spot in Best Suction-Side Pool Cleaners?
Global Critique
“The best suction-side cleaner you can buy — the self-adjusting flow means it works on nearly any pump.”
“Climbs walls, handles steps, and just keeps going for years. The benchmark in its class.”
“No electronics to break and a fraction of a robot's price. Just be ready to clean your filter more often.”
More from Best Suction-Side Pool Cleaners.
See how other top picks compare in this category.



